Why ETFs are tanking faster than physical metal

Gold and silver prices tumbled on January 22, 2026, but the real shock came from ETFs, which fell sharply—highlighting the growing gap between physical bullion and digital investments in India.

Investors woke up to a market twist on Thursday: while 24-karat gold dropped to Rs 1,51,575 per 10 grams and silver traded at Rs 3,301 per 10 grams, gold and silver ETFs on the NSE fell dramatically—Tata Silver ETF plunged 13.6%, and gold ETFs saw losses of 8–10%.

The discrepancy sparked curiosity: why did digital funds fall so much more than the actual metals? Analysts point to profit booking, global economic cues, and investor psychology. When ETFs are traded like stocks, mass sell-offs can exaggerate price swings, even if the underlying commodity hasn’t moved as drastically.

“This is a reminder that ETFs and physical gold behave differently,” said market expert Amar Ranu. “Short-term volatility in ETFs can be high, but long-term value remains anchored in the actual metal.”

Also read: Nagercoil–Mangaluru Amrit Bharat Express to run via Kottayam; Service on Tuesdays and Wednesdays

Why this matters now:

Investors are increasingly moving between digital ETFs and physical bullion, searching for safety amid global uncertainty.

Silver’s volatility is drawing attention: it’s not just jewellery, it’s industrial demand too, which fuels price swings.

The trend hints at a new era where retail investors must differentiate between owning “real” gold and trading paper gold.

City-wise snapshot:

• Chennai: 24K gold ₹1,57,270 / 10g, silver ₹3,451 / 10g
• Mumbai: 24K gold ₹1,56,610 / 10g, silver ₹3,301 / 10g
• Delhi: 24K gold ₹1,56,760 / 10g, silver ₹3,301 / 10g

Investor takeaway:

Short-term panic may drive ETF prices down sharply, but physical gold and silver remain safe-haven assets. Experts advise long-term allocation, SIP-based silver purchases, and not reacting to headline volatility.

The lesson? In India’s evolving bullion market, owning metal is not the same as trading it digitally. For investors, today’s sharp ETF falls are a wake-up call to understand the tools they are using—and to separate hype from actual value.

(Disclaimer: The gold and silver prices mentioned in this article are for informational purposes only and are based on market updates at the time of writing. Prices are subject to change due to market volatility, currency fluctuations, and other economic factors. Readers should verify rates with authorised dealers or exchanges before making any investment decisions. The publisher and authors do not take responsibility for any financial losses.)

Published: 22 Jan 2026, 05:05 pm IST

Disclaimer: Kindly avoid objectionable, derogatory, unlawful and lewd comments, while responding to reports. Such comments are punishable under cyber laws. Please keep away from personal attacks. The opinions expressed here are the personal opinions of readers and not that of Mathrubhumi.