If you are retired or approaching retirement, you have probably parked a chunk of your savings in a high-yield savings account and felt pretty good about it. After all, earning around 4% APY on money you can pull out at any time sounds like a solid deal.
But there is another option sitting right next to it on the shelf that most retirees never hear about. It pays a higher guaranteed rate, grows tax-deferred, and does not require you to watch the stock market. The catch is that it asks you to leave your money alone for a few years.
The product is called a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity, or MYGA, and for retirees who have savings they will not need for three to seven years, the numbers right now are hard to ignore.
MYGA rates are outpacing high-yield savings accounts right now
The rate gap between MYGAs and high-yield savings accounts has widened considerably. As of March 2026, top A-rated MYGA providers are offering guaranteed rates between 5.00% and 5.75% on three- to seven-year terms, according to data from Annuity Expert Advice. The best five-year MYGA rate from a rated carrier sits at 6.30%.
Compare that to the high-yield savings account landscape. According to NerdWallet’s March 2026 survey, the top HYSAs are paying around 4.00% to 4.21% APY, while the FDIC’s national average savings rate remains just 0.39%.
That is a difference of roughly 1 to 2 full percentage points between the best MYGA and the best HYSA. On a $100,000 deposit over five years, even a 1.5-percentage-point difference translates to thousands of dollars in additional earnings before you even factor in the tax advantage.
How a MYGA actually works and who should consider one
A MYGA is a fixed annuity issued by an insurance company. You deposit a lump sum, choose a term length, and the insurer locks in a guaranteed interest rate for the full duration. Your principal is protected, there is no stock market exposure, and your money compounds at the same rate every year.
Related: Retirement Savings Solutions to Weather Stormy Markets
Terms typically range from three to ten years. Most carriers require a minimum deposit between $5,000 and $25,000, though the most competitive rates tend to kick in at $100,000 or more, according to My Annuity Store’s 2026 guide.
Key features that separate MYGAs from savings accounts
-
Your rate is fixed for the full term. It does not fluctuate with Fed decisions or bank policy changes.
-
Interest grows tax-deferred. You owe no income tax on earnings until you make a withdrawal.
-
Most contracts allow a 10% penalty-free withdrawal each year if you need limited access to funds.
-
MYGAs are not FDIC insured. They are backed by the issuing insurance company’s claims-paying ability and your state’s guaranty association, which typically covers $100,000 to $500,000.
-
If you withdraw more than the free amount before the term ends, you will face surrender charges that can run as high as 10% of the withdrawal.
The ideal MYGA buyer is someone in or near retirement who has a portion of their savings earmarked for a specific future need, such as covering living expenses starting in five years, funding a future home purchase, or simply growing a stable reserve outside the stock market.
The tax-deferred advantage retirees often overlook
This is where MYGAs pull further ahead for retirees, and it is a detail that does not show up in a simple rate comparison. With a high-yield savings account, you owe federal income tax on every dollar of interest earned each year, even if you do not withdraw a cent. If you are in the 22% or 24% federal tax bracket, that reduces your effective return immediately.
With a MYGA, your earnings compound tax-deferred for the entire term. You do not owe taxes until you take money out. On a $200,000 deposit over five years, My Annuity Store estimates this difference can add $8,000 to $15,000 to your net return compared to a CD or savings account, depending on your tax bracket.
A simple comparison on $100,000 over five years
-
HYSA at 4.00% APY (taxed annually at 22%): Roughly $116,500 after taxes
-
MYGA at 5.50% (tax-deferred, taxed at withdrawal): Roughly $128,200 before tax on gains, with the flexibility to manage when you realize that income
The ability to control when you pay taxes is especially valuable in retirement. You can time withdrawals to fall in lower-income years or spread them across multiple tax years to stay in a lower bracket.
Where high-yield savings accounts still win
MYGAs are not the right tool for every dollar you have. If you need your money within the next year or two, a high-yield savings account remains the better choice. You get full liquidity, FDIC insurance up to $250,000 per depositor per institution, and no penalties for pulling funds out at any time.
Situations where an HYSA makes more sense
-
Your emergency fund. This money needs to be accessible immediately without penalties or waiting periods.
-
Short-term savings goals. If you are saving for a purchase or expense within the next 6 to 18 months, locking your money into a multi-year contract does not make sense.
-
Funds you may need unexpectedly. Medical bills, home repairs, or family emergencies require liquidity that a MYGA cannot provide without a cost.
The Federal Reserve held rates steady at its January 2026 meeting, keeping the federal funds rate between 3.50% and 3.75%. HYSA rates have been trending lower since late 2024. That makes the case for locking in a MYGA rate now even stronger for money you will not need soon.
The risks and trade-offs you need to understand before buying a MYGA
MYGAs are among the simplest annuity products available, but they are not risk-free. Before you commit, you need to understand what you are giving up:
Surrender charges can be steep
If you withdraw more than the annual penalty-free amount before your term ends, the insurer will charge a surrender fee. These fees typically start at 7% to 10% in the first year and decline gradually. If you have any doubt about needing the money early, a MYGA is not the right vehicle for that portion of your savings.
MYGAs are not FDIC insured
Your deposit is backed by the insurance company’s financial strength, not the federal government. That is why financial professionals strongly recommend choosing carriers rated A- or better by AM Best.
Your state’s guaranty association provides an additional safety net, typically covering between $100,000 and $500,000 depending on where you live.
Early withdrawal before age 59½ triggers a tax penalty
If you withdraw earnings from a MYGA before reaching 59½, the IRS imposes a 10% early withdrawal penalty on top of regular income taxes, according to IRS guidelines on annuity distributions. This makes MYGAs a better fit for people who are at or near traditional retirement age.
You could miss out on rising rates
Once you lock in a MYGA rate, you are committed for the full term. If rates rise significantly during that period, your money is stuck earning the lower guaranteed rate. One way to manage this risk is through laddering, which means splitting your deposit across MYGAs with different maturity dates so a portion comes due every year or two.
How to decide which option fits your retirement plan
The answer is not MYGA or HYSA. For most retirees, the answer is both. The practical approach is to think about your savings in buckets.
A framework for splitting your savings
-
Bucket 1: Immediate access (HYSA). Keep six to twelve months of living expenses in a high-yield savings account for emergencies and near-term spending.
-
Bucket 2: Medium-term growth (MYGA). Savings you will not need for three to seven years can earn a higher guaranteed rate in a MYGA while growing tax-deferred.
-
Bucket 3: Long-term growth (investments). Money with a horizon of seven-plus years belongs in a diversified investment portfolio for growth potential that outpaces inflation over time.
More Employment:
This is not a one-size-fits-all formula. Your specific allocation depends on your monthly expenses, other income sources like Social Security and pensions, your health, and your risk tolerance.
If you are unsure about how to split things up, a fee-only financial advisor who does not earn commissions on product sales can help you build a plan tailored to your situation.
Practical steps if you are ready to explore MYGAs
If the rate advantage and tax-deferred growth appeal to you, here is how to move forward without making a costly mistake.
-
Determine your available lump sum: Only commit money you are confident you will not need for the full term. Do not touch your emergency fund or near-term reserves.
-
Compare rates from A-rated carriers: Use rate comparison tools from sources like Blueprint Income, Annuity Expert Advice, or Immediate Annuities. Always verify the insurer’s AM Best rating is A- or higher.
-
Consider a laddering strategy: Instead of putting everything into one five-year MYGA, split your deposit across three, four, and five-year terms so one matures each year.
-
Decide between qualified and non-qualified funding: You can fund a MYGA with IRA money (qualified) or personal savings (non-qualified). The tax treatment at withdrawal differs, so understand the implications before you choose.
-
Read the surrender schedule carefully: Know exactly what fees apply if you need to access more than the annual free withdrawal amount before maturity.
MYGA rates remain near 15-year highs heading into spring 2026. If the Fed continues its gradual easing, those rates may not stay at these levels much longer. For retirees sitting on excess cash in a savings account, this is a window worth taking seriously.
This story was originally published by TheStreet on Mar 14, 2026, where it first appeared in the Retirement section. Add TheStreet as a Preferred Source by clicking here.